Miscellaneous, Page 8

Proof of a Creator:  A Rejoinder to Theodore Schick, Jr. (continued)


Dr. Schick rebuts this argument as follows:


“This argument arrives at the conclusion that the universe has a beginning in time by assuming that the universe has a cause. But the big bang argument uses the premise that the universe has a beginning in time to arrive at the conclusion that the universe has a cause. So Ross is arguing in a circle. He is assuming that the universe has a cause to prove that the universe has a cause. Because Ross begs the question about whether the universe has a cause, he does not succeed in proving the existence of a higher dimensional time, let alone the existence of a transcendental god.”


Dr. Schick is correct.  It is, therefore, my intention within this essay to attempt to provide the justification that Dr. Ross’s argument lacks to assume that the big bang (and, therefore, the universe) had a cause.  For the benefit of my argument, I appeal to none other than perhaps the most venerated, self-professed atheist in scientific history,  Albert Einstein himself!  It is an understatement to judge it ironic that I perceive that such a renowned atheist proved, albeit unwittingly, the existence of God or, more precisely, a creator of at least some sort.


It was Hermann Minkowski, Dr. Einstein’s erstwhile math teacher, who first pointed out to him that his special theory of relativity implied a four-dimensional universe, now usually referred to as the "block universe.”  In this scheme of reality, time is reduced to a mere fourth dimension, with the result being that the universe can no longer be viewed as being composed of space and time, but rather as an unified structure called  “spacetime,”  with all events within the universe (including particles seemingly being created without a cause via vacuum fluctuations) occurring at the confluence of four-dimensional points.


(For example:  September 11, 2001, the World Trade Center at the precise floor and instant that the first plane hit.)  


Dr. Einstein himself was at first most reluctant to accept such a view of reality, but eventually came to embrace it.  Here lies the point most relevant to the thrust of this essay:  Within the block universe scheme of reality, the past, present and future of spacetime all exist contemporaneously and there is no privileged moment within spacetime soley entitled to call itself  "the present"  or "now." Click to continue:




Miscellaneous, 9